About Long Island Pizza

Long Island Pizza brings a laid-back neighborhood feel to the pizza scene at 435 Hepburn St, Williamsport, Pennsylvania, making it a convenient stop for anyone craving fresh slices, hearty comfort food, and quick casual meals throughout the day. The moment you hear the name Long Island Pizza, it already sounds like the kind of spot where oversized pies, crispy crusts, and satisfying late-night bites are part of the experience. The restaurant keeps things approachable and relaxed, which makes it easy for locals, students, families, and groups of friends to swing by for dine-in meals or grab takeout on busy evenings. Outdoor seating adds another layer of comfort, especially during warmer days when people want to enjoy pizza in an open-air setting without rushing through their meal.

One thing that stands out about Long Island Pizza is the flexibility it offers customers. Some people stop in for a quick bite between errands, while others rely on the no-contact delivery and curbside pickup options when staying home feels easier. Delivery service also helps make the restaurant a dependable option for casual dinners, game nights, or late-night cravings when cooking simply is not happening. The menu style fits perfectly with the classic pizza restaurant atmosphere, offering familiar comfort food that feels filling without trying too hard to be trendy.

Vegetarian options help broaden the appeal, giving groups more variety when ordering multiple dishes or small plates to share around the table. The casual vibe works especially well because nothing feels overly formal or complicated here. Instead, Long Island Pizza focuses on the kind of food people genuinely return for: hot pizza, satisfying portions, and fast service that fits everyday life. Whether someone wants a simple slice, a full pie for the family, or an easy late-night meal after a long day, the restaurant delivers that easygoing neighborhood pizza experience people usually hope to find but rarely do this consistently.

Icon
Icon

Business Info

Service options

Service options

+ Outdoor seating

+ Curbside pickup

+ No-contact delivery

+ Delivery

+ Onsite services

+ Takeout

+ Dine-in

Popular for

Popular for

+ Lunch

+ Dinner

+ Solo dining

Accessibility

Accessibility

+ Wheelchair accessible entrance

+ Wheelchair accessible parking lot

+ Wheelchair accessible restroom

+ Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings

Offerings

+ Comfort food

+ Late-night food

+ Quick bite

+ Small plates

+ Vegetarian options

Dining options

Dining options

+ Lunch

+ Dinner

+ Catering

+ Counter service

+ Dessert

+ Seating

Amenities

Amenities

+ Restroom

Atmosphere

Atmosphere

+ Casual

+ Cozy

+ Quiet

Crowd

Crowd

+ College students

+ Family-friendly

+ Groups

+ Tourists

Planning

Planning

+ No Accepts reservations

Payments

Payments

+ Credit cards

+ Debit cards

+ NFC mobile payments

Children

Children

+ Good for kids

+ High chairs

+ Kids' menu

Parking

Parking

+ Free parking lot

+ Free street parking

+ Parking

Pets

Pets

+ Dogs allowed outside

Icon

Hour time open

Right Now :

  • Monday: Closed
  • Tuesday: 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
  • Wednesday: 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
  • Thursday: 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
  • Friday: 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
  • Saturday: 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
  • Sunday: Closed
Icon
Order Now

+1 570-601-3463

435 Hepburn St, Williamsport, PA 17701, United States

Reviews

Icon

I haven’t been here In years but when I walked in nothing changed. The owner greets you the. Thanks you for your business when you leave. Knots that dominos and chains sell for a killing are three for a dollar and are a lot bigger and better. I bought and Stromboli and it was great and the sauce was awesome. I would highly recommend if your in the area or near by. Talk about a small business that cares about its customers this is the spot in Williamsport.

- Jason Ostroskie -

Icon

I ordered takeout and as I walked in, I was greeted immediately by friendly staff. The two guys at the front were really nice, and my order was already sitting on the counter. The pepperoni New York style pizza was delicious. This was the best dining experience that I have ever had, and I can't wait to come back!

- Davis Graham -

Icon

WOW! As a long time trucker it’s hard to find good food! Long Island Pizza delivered me the utmost best pizza and by far the best wings I’ve had! Thank you Long Island Pizza!

- Dexter Scott -

Icon

Man, this was delicious! We had a change of plans and ended up here. What a happy accident! We had the large Taco and large Bohemian. Outstanding! The crust was thick, with a nice crisp outside and soft, tender interior. The toppings were very generous. We also shared a piece of cheesecake, which was equally wonderful. We'll definitely be back to try the Seafood pizza!

- Jordan Adams -

Icon

We found this hidden gem on Google and so glad we did! The owner and staff are great. The pizza is amazing! The owner makes the dough and his own sauce. We dined in Thursday night and had the buffalo chicken pizza which was so good! Seriously one of the best we've found traveling around the U.S. Tonight neither of us were up for going out so we decided on delivery from here again. I know pizza 2 days in a row. No regrets! The taco pizza was just as good! I usually don't eat the crust but it is so good that I couldn't resist. The prices are good, combos/specials are available, cleanliness was 10/10 even the stove hood was clean! Great staff! The delivery guy was tentative and friendly. We come to town twice a year and this will be a must for us every time! Pictured is the large buffalo chicken pizza. Thank you Long Island Pizza for a great pizza and experience.

- Rachel Long -

Icon

OMG so delicious, I paused in the middle of meal to write this.. the Pizza amaaaaazing... I also ordered cheesesteaks and they did not disappoint. Will be ordering from here again for sure!.. plus the delivery was faster than expected! Kind and courteous service from phone call to delivery

- Stephanie Watson -

Icon

I love pizza, grew up in an Italian home, lived in NYC and always seek out pizza in my travels. I was pleasantly surprised with how good this pizza was! (In a very small town in the middle of nowhere ). The sauce was good, sausages delicious, and the crust was very good. The vegetable one was full of veggies and my vegetarian son loved it. The cheese ones were excellent. And it was ready when they said! I’d go back if I’m ever here again! Priced very reasonably

- John Elmer -

Icon

All I can say is that the holy spirit is filled in that restaurant! So welcome as soon as you step in the door you feel the love Thank you so much for all the positive energy!! My husband is in the oil field and I took him here they helped me bring his faith walk back amen

- N -

Try these next time!

Cafe Hope Coffee Shop And Eatery
  • Coffee Shop
Cafe Hope Coffee Shop And Eatery

1151 Barataria Blvd Suite 1000, Marrero, LA 70072, United States

Restaurant Daily Dose
  • Italian Restaurant
Restaurant Daily Dose

Hämeentie 68, 00550 Helsinki, Finland

1924 Riverfront Steakhouse
  • Restaurant
1924 Riverfront Steakhouse

1 Wharf Rd, Murray Bridge SA 5253, Australia

Le Pré Gourmet
  • Restaurant
Le Pré Gourmet

3 Rue Henriette des Garets, 42122 Saint-Marcel-de-Félines, France

Masala Meats And Takeout
  • Takeout Restaurant
Masala Meats And Takeout

272 Kinniburgh Blvd #104, Chestermere, AB T1X 2P2, Canada

Sumo Sushi Restaurant
  • Japanese Restaurant
Sumo Sushi Restaurant

Sector # 13 Plot# 18 Road#, Gausul Azam Ave, Dhaka 1230, Bangladesh